Italian Privacy Violation Case Wednesday Could Set Dangerous Precedent

BY CCIA Staff
February 17, 2009

The Computer & Communications Industry Association will be among those monitoring the outcome of a privacy violation case Wednesday (February 18) in Italy. Several Google executives face up to 3 years in prison over a YouTube video. The video, which showed a disabled student being harassed, was identified and taken down within 24 hours by Google employees, whose actions helped lead to the prosecution of those responsible for the video. But the executives are still facing criminal penalties.

The following comments on this case can be attributed to Ed Black, CCIA President and CEO:

“This case could set a terrible precedent. Criminally prosecuting companies, whose main purpose is legitimately facilitating the open flow of information, resembles criminal law on steroids.

“This case is bad law and worse policy. To hold Google employees liable in this context is no more sensible than holding postal service snail mail routemen or email service employees liable for what is written in the messages they carry. Hate speech letters or video sent by any means is despicable, but criminal sanctions are unfair when applied widely against peripheral “non” actors. Seeking to hold neutral Internet platforms liable for content posted by others, is a dangerous threat to a free, open Internet. It would directly and unjustifiably threaten thousands of legitimate companies. The U.S. government and all multinational firms should express their concern and outrage over such unjustified expansionist use of criminal law.”

Related Articles

CCIA, Industry and Civil Society Groups Send Joint Letter To EU Policymakers On Preventing Terrorist Content Online

Sep 21, 2020

CCIA, industry and civil society groups today sent a letter to EU policy-makers on the proposal on preventing the dissemination of terrorist content online.  CCIA fully supports the objective of the EU institutions to counter terrorism and incitement to violence. The joint letter encouraged EU policymakers to define a clear scope and definition of terrorist…

European Commission Issues Temporary Rules to Allow Companies to Continue Removal of Online Child Sexual Abuse Material

Sep 10, 2020

Brussels, BELGIUM — The European Commission published a proposed Regulation today allowing online communications providers to continue to detect and remove child sexual abuse material (CSAM) from their services.  This proposal is designed to make up for an unintended consequence of the existing e-Privacy Directive, which will apply to online messaging services as of 21…

CCIA Responds to the European Commission Consultation on Article 17 of the Copyright Directive

Sep 10, 2020

Brussels, BELGIUM –The Computer & Communications Industry Association offered comments on the implementation of Article 17 of the Copyright Directive today. CCIA’s comments include elements such as the scope of services covered, how online content-sharing service providers have to provide their ‘best efforts’ to obtain rightsholders’ authorisation, and avoiding unauthorised content online.  After months of…