Italian Privacy Violation Case Wednesday Could Set Dangerous Precedent

BY CCIA Staff
February 17, 2009

The Computer & Communications Industry Association will be among those monitoring the outcome of a privacy violation case Wednesday (February 18) in Italy. Several Google executives face up to 3 years in prison over a YouTube video. The video, which showed a disabled student being harassed, was identified and taken down within 24 hours by Google employees, whose actions helped lead to the prosecution of those responsible for the video. But the executives are still facing criminal penalties.

The following comments on this case can be attributed to Ed Black, CCIA President and CEO:

“This case could set a terrible precedent. Criminally prosecuting companies, whose main purpose is legitimately facilitating the open flow of information, resembles criminal law on steroids.

“This case is bad law and worse policy. To hold Google employees liable in this context is no more sensible than holding postal service snail mail routemen or email service employees liable for what is written in the messages they carry. Hate speech letters or video sent by any means is despicable, but criminal sanctions are unfair when applied widely against peripheral “non” actors. Seeking to hold neutral Internet platforms liable for content posted by others, is a dangerous threat to a free, open Internet. It would directly and unjustifiably threaten thousands of legitimate companies. The U.S. government and all multinational firms should express their concern and outrage over such unjustified expansionist use of criminal law.”

Related Articles

CCIA Warns EU Foreign Subsidies Plan Could Deter Investment Needed for Economic Recovery

Dec 17, 2021

Brussels, BELGIUM — The Computer & Communications Industry Association (CCIA Europe) backs the European Commission’s crackdown on distortive foreign subsidies but fears that the proposal, as it stands, could inadvertently discourage third-country organisations from providing the investment required to help fund Europe’s post-pandemic recovery. In its position paper on the EU Regulation on foreign subsidies,…

CCIA Responds to EU consultation on Civil liability and AI

Dec 17, 2021

Today, the Computer & Communications Industry Association submitted its comments to the European Commission’s public consultation “Civil liability – adapting liability rules to the digital age and artificial intelligence”. CCIA Europe acknowledges the Commission’s concerns that certain elements of emerging technologies like Artificial Intelligence (AI) could pose new challenges to the application of liability rules.…

CCIA Encourages Trilogue Negotiations to Focus on Making the Digital Markets Act Workable

Dec 15, 2021

Brussels, BELGIUM — Today the European Parliament adopted its negotiating position on the Digital Markets Act (DMA), largely adopting the amendments approved by the committee on Internal Market and Consumer Protection, which is leading in the proposal. With the Council of Ministers of the European Union having recently agreed on their ‘general approach’, this milestone…