TPI Antitrust Event Offers Company Side Of Debate

BY CCIA Staff
October 25, 2010

The Technology Policy Institute reviewed major past antitrust cases before looking to the future and the potential for regulators to jump in on issues like cloud computing. Panelists at the Friday event, organized by the conservative think tank, discussed antitrust law and enforcement in the high-tech sector.

The first panel focused on how antitrust enforcement action in recent decades against IBM, AT&T, Microsoft, and Intel has impacted those companies.  In evaluating these cases, presenters noted that in each case, the ultimate source of change in the competitive landscape had little to do with antitrust litigation, but was spurred on by innovation and new technologies.  They assert that in prior technology cases, government was unable to see how technology would develop over time, and because this lack of foresight continues to exist, antitrust remedies in the tech sector should not be intrusive.

In looking at data on Intel, its competitors, and consumers since the outset of the investigation of the chipmaker, a presenter concluded that despite the illegal rebates that Intel offered, the fine and order to stop it is not helping consumers yet. He also suggested antitrust enforcement in the technology sector impedes innovation  — without achieving its primary goal of protecting consumers.

But Joseph Farrell, director of the bureau of economics at the Federal Trade Commission took issue with those asserting that antitrust is incompatible with the techn industry. He said that where there is a lack of evidence on the impact enforcement will have on innovation, the appropriate action is for government to enforce the law — and protect customers and competition.

CCIA agrees with Farrell. After nearly 40 years of monitoring and weighing in on antitrust policy in the high tech sector, CCIA understands the problem of misusing the tool. But we have long believed it is necessary to have antitrust cops on the beat so that entrenched big companies do not try to snuff out the next big innovation or disruptive technology — simply to protect their own business model.

Because the tech sector depends heavily on interoperability for its products and apps to work, there is more opportunity than in most industries for bad behavior that squelches innovation. Too little antitrust enforcement is as dangerous as too much for the high tech industry.

The second panel focused on new and emerging markets and technologies and the potential impact of antitrust enforcement and regulation.  Panelists examined issues such as net neutrality, vertical integration in technology firms, and cloud computing and argued that government regulation wouldn’t help and would instead lead to evasion of the new regulations.

Panelists said antitrust law does not need to be amended or updated for the high-tech industry – and that authorities charged with protecting consumers should be cautious about intervening as that could harm some businesses.

Related Articles

CCIA Comments Ahead of House Antitrust Subcommittee Hearing This Week

Feb 24, 2021

Washington — House Judiciary Antitrust Subcommittee Chairman David Cicilline resumes his attack on the tech industry this week with a hearing Thursday. The Committee held numerous hearings during the last Congress to build support for additional regulation, with Computer & Communications Industry Association President Matt Schruers as one of the witnesses at the lead-off hearing.…

CCIA, Industry Groups File Complaint Against Maryland Digital Tax

Feb 18, 2021

Washington — The Computer & Communications Industry Association and a coalition of trade associations joined in filing a federal complaint against Maryland’s recent Act imposing a “Digital Advertising Gross Revenues Tax”, aimed at technology companies. The Act attempts to collect an estimated $250 million from a small number of companies in the first year, according…

CCIA’s Response As Chairman Klobuchar Introduces Antitrust Bill

Feb 4, 2021

Washington — The incoming chair of the Senate antitrust subcommittee, Amy Klobuchar, D-Minn., is introducing an antitrust bill Thursday according to various news reports, which proposes fundamental changes to U.S. antitrust law. The bill includes new merger regulations, funding for antitrust enforcers, the ability to issue civil fines against companies and also eliminate the need…