CCIA Files Petition With FCC Asking To Deny AT&T Merger

BY CCIA Staff
May 31, 2011

The Computer & Communications Industry Association, which has advocated for 39 years for competition policy that fosters innovation and allows the next start up and smaller competitors to have a chance to succeed, filed a petition with the FCC Tuesday asking it to deny AT&T’s proposal to take over its competing wireless carrier, T-Mobile.
Technology companies from handset makers to gaming systems to Internet applications increasingly depend on wireless access to reach their customers. They need spectrum and Internet users need the ability to reach the wireless apps of their choice, so the merger, giving AT&T more power and control over these elements is a threat – given AT&T’s past anticompetitive behavior.
CCIA was actively involved in the original breakup of AT&T in 1984, which helped create a dynamic and competitive environment that has allowed numerous innovations like Skype and the iPhone to flourish. CCIA offered FCC examples of AT&T’s past anticompetitive behavior in its petition and asked that the government block the merger.
The following statement can be attributed to Ed Black:
“CCIA used the FCC’s own market data in its “Fourteenth Report” to illustrate the market concentration that would result from this merger and why it should be denied. If wireless competition were allowed to further erode there would be few remedies to get it back. We urge others who are wary of over regulation to also oppose this merger so that greater regulation is not needed down the road to clean up the mess this merger would create.
“Innovation from operating systems to handsets could be held back or blocked from ever reaching the marketplace. AT&T has blocked numerous innovations that have competed with its business model in the past from fax machines to cell phones and this brazen merger proposal makes it clear they are once again seeking market power which will allow them to hold back innovation and maximize profits. Why would we once again install them as gatekeeper?
“AT&T says it is facing a spectrum crunch, despite being the largest spectrum holder in 21 major markets. AT&T got into this position because it failed to invest more fully in its network. They may try to argue that they’ll be good this time, stop warehousing spectrum and build out to rural areas. But why is that credible, given their history and track record?”
“There are no conditions available to the Commission that would allow the second largest wireless carrier to buy the fourth largest carrier and still meet the test for somehow being in the public interest. It is not. No amount of lipstick, lobbying tactics by AT&T or legal maneuvering with conditions can change the facts of this case. This merger would raise prices for consumers and small businesses with mobile phones and Internet connections and dampen innovation. It is contrary to antitrust law, and against the public interest and must be stopped.”
“As the FCC reviews competition in the wireless market, AT&T’s history and its own precedent in prior mergers, we believe they will conclude that this proposal SHOULD be summarily denied. We hope the Commission quickly grants our petition and the similar ones from others in industry and consumers’ groups so that the competitive damage to T-Mobile during this consideration is minimized.”

Related Articles

CCIA Comments Ahead of House Antitrust Subcommittee Hearing This Week

Feb 24, 2021

Washington — House Judiciary Antitrust Subcommittee Chairman David Cicilline resumes his attack on the tech industry this week with a hearing Thursday. The Committee held numerous hearings during the last Congress to build support for additional regulation, with Computer & Communications Industry Association President Matt Schruers as one of the witnesses at the lead-off hearing.…

CCIA’s Response As Chairman Klobuchar Introduces Antitrust Bill

Feb 4, 2021

Washington — The incoming chair of the Senate antitrust subcommittee, Amy Klobuchar, D-Minn., is introducing an antitrust bill Thursday according to various news reports, which proposes fundamental changes to U.S. antitrust law. The bill includes new merger regulations, funding for antitrust enforcers, the ability to issue civil fines against companies and also eliminate the need…

CCIA Cautions Against Australian Proposal To Impose Mandatory Bargaining Code on Select U.S. Tech Firms

Jan 22, 2021

Washington – Australia’s Parliament is considering legislation to introduce a controversial Code of Conduct that would require certain U.S. internet companies to subsidize local news content producers by imposing obligations such as payment for links to news content.  The Computer & Communications Industry Association has advocated for access to information online for more than two…