Consumer, Business Associations Oppose AT&T Merger

BY Heather Greenfield
May 10, 2011

Consumer and business groups voiced their opposition to the AT&T merger proposal a day ahead of a hearing on Capitol Hill. The Senate Judiciary subcommittee hearing, “The AT&T/T-Mobile Merger: Is Humpty Dumpty Being Put Back Together Again?” will be webcast.
CCIA President & CEO Ed Black said there has been tremendous innovation in the tech sector since the break up of AT&T in the 1980s for denying fair interconnectivity to a competitor. Public Knowledge President Gigi Sohn said the mobile phone market became competitive in 1993 after Congress authorized the FCC to hold spectrum auctions.
“The merger threatens to completely undo what Congress did in 1993 and recreate a duopoly,” Sohn said. “If antitrust law means anything in this country, this merger must be denied.”
Rural Cellular Association President & CEO Steve Berry said, “If you have over 30 percent market share, that’s illegal for a merger.”
Media Access Project director Andy Schwartzman added that antitrust laws recognize that maverick companies like T-Mobile are especially important to preserve, saying the mobile market would be less innovative and more expensive for all customers without T-Mobile.
“T-Mobile has been a leader in offering low priced plans — $15-50 less than comparable AT&T plans,” Schwartzman said.
“Based on the merits, or lack of merit, the merger should be easily disapproved – without political influence to support it,” Black told reporters. But he agreed that money and politics are important in Washington and noted AT&T has a massive political action machine that has given money to Congressional campaigns for decades.
“They need to do this because the deal is vulnerable on the merits. If AT&T fools people on the reality of the market and give misinformation, they may get some members of Congress to support this,” Black said in response to a reporters’ question about Congressional support.
“A lot of folks whether Republican or Democrat see this [merger] as unthinkable and they’re shocked this could even be proposed to begin with,” Sohn said.

Related Articles

CCIA Comments Ahead of House Antitrust Subcommittee Hearing This Week

Feb 24, 2021

Washington — House Judiciary Antitrust Subcommittee Chairman David Cicilline resumes his attack on the tech industry this week with a hearing Thursday. The Committee held numerous hearings during the last Congress to build support for additional regulation, with Computer & Communications Industry Association President Matt Schruers as one of the witnesses at the lead-off hearing.…

CCIA’s Response As Chairman Klobuchar Introduces Antitrust Bill

Feb 4, 2021

Washington — The incoming chair of the Senate antitrust subcommittee, Amy Klobuchar, D-Minn., is introducing an antitrust bill Thursday according to various news reports, which proposes fundamental changes to U.S. antitrust law. The bill includes new merger regulations, funding for antitrust enforcers, the ability to issue civil fines against companies and also eliminate the need…

CCIA Cautions Against Australian Proposal To Impose Mandatory Bargaining Code on Select U.S. Tech Firms

Jan 22, 2021

Washington – Australia’s Parliament is considering legislation to introduce a controversial Code of Conduct that would require certain U.S. internet companies to subsidize local news content producers by imposing obligations such as payment for links to news content.  The Computer & Communications Industry Association has advocated for access to information online for more than two…