Senate Judiciary Committee Embraces French Proposal for Internet Regulation

BY CCIA Staff
May 26, 2011

Within 48 hours of French President Sarkozy proposing sweeping international regulation of the Internet at the eG-8 meeting, the U.S. Senate Judiciary Committee approved a bill allowing the U.S. Department of Justice to blacklist Internet sites and regulate certain industries having contact with those sites.

The newly introduced S. 968 is a stronger version of the controversial, Hollywood-backed COICA bill that was blocked last year. The Senate Judiciary Committee approved it today a voice vote during a meeting that was closed to the public.

The Computer & Communications Industry Association, which fights Internet filtering and censorship at home and abroad, opposes this approach to Internet regulation.

“We had feared that the U.S. Government might backslide toward the French approach to Internet regulation that was rejected so emphatically earlier this week, but we didn’t expect it this soon,” said CCIA President & CEO Ed Black.

“At a time when U.S. businesses are increasing confronted with barriers to Internet trade and censorship abroad, a government committed to Internet openness should not be in the business of blacklisting Internet sites,” Black added.

The Protect IP Act (PIPA, S. 968) proposes to empower the U.S. Attorney General, and in some cases private copyright owners to obtain court orders requiring the blocking of sites that meet a broad statutory definition of “dedicated to infringing activities”.  Sites that may be subject to this regulation include domain name servers, search engines and other sites using directories, indexes, or hyperlinks, payment processors, and advertising networks.

The bill was blocked last year after prominent Internet scientists and engineers warned it would break the Internet. Several released another report  explaining the risks to the Internet itself if domains were blocked in this way and search results are manipulated to erase results that could contain infringing material.

Black published an op ed in the San Francisco Chronicle this week warning of the risks to the Internet with this legislation that will, unfortunately, in the end fail to block the problem of online infringement.

Related Articles

CCIA Requests Hearing on Senate Antitrust Venue Bill Ahead of Markup

Aug 10, 2021

Washington — The Computer & Communications Industry Association sent a letter today asking the Senate Judiciary Committee to hold a hearing on S. 1787, State Antitrust Enforcement Venue Act of 2021. Antitrust litigation often involves multiple states which, absent the possibility to centralize under one venue, would risk having balkanized antitrust judgments with multiple and…

CCIA Supports Efforts to Address Censorship Practices, Digital Trade Barriers in China Legislation

May 27, 2021

Washington, DC — The Computer & Communications Industry Association (CCIA) supports efforts by Senator Wyden and others to include language in the U.S. Innovation and Competition Act to address foreign censorship practices and strengthen the ability of the Office of the U.S. Trade Representative to combat digital trade barriers. Foreign censorship practices by authoritarian regimes,…

USTR Announces Sanctions Against France in Digital Tax Investigation

Jul 10, 2020

Washington — USTR has announced sanctions against France that will remain suspended until France starts collecting duties under the French digital services tax. This follows USTR’s conclusion in the Section 301 investigation into the French tax that the tax discriminated against US firms.  Several countries are in various stages of implementing digital taxes targeted at…