Breakfast with Edward Snowden

March 16, 2015

Austin — I wasn’t expecting it. Dinner with the Irish Taoiseach Enda Kenny (Prime Minister). After dinner drinks with Hulk Hogan. Breakfast the next morning with Edward Snowden. Not dining companions I was expecting.

The unifying factor for this unlikely combination: The SXSW festival in Austin, Texas.

Hulk Hogan’s session on content was fascinating and that Enda Kenny did a great job attracting technology companies to Ireland. But the biggest draw, for me, was Edward Snowden.

A small group snuck into the convention centre early in the morning for a video conference session organised by the American Civil Liberties Union. Snowden wasn’t there in person, but a black shirted figure, against a black background, on a TV screen from somewhere in Russia. This was the first time I had come face to face (so to speak) with the man who changed so much in global politics and the way we think of our digital lives.

How was he, I hear you say? Normal, is the answer. When speaking his delivery was calm, measured, knowledgeable. He talked in a thoughtful manner when answering the questions we threw at him. He did not seem like a man under stress.

But this is a policy blog, so you didn’t come for gossip on personality. You want to know what he said.

In short, Snowden thinks that governments won’t reform surveillance practices in a meaningful way and that it’s up to technology companies to find solutions. Not only that, but talk by democratic governments of requiring ‘backdoors’ will mean that autocratic regimes will jump on the legitimation this provides.

Technological solutions can ‘raise the cost’ of accessing communications meaning that surveillance agencies concentrate on important targets rather than everything Snowden pointed out. This begins with top technology companies pooling resources to research vulnerabilities, he believes. Disguising VPN traffic so that it doesn’t look like VPN traffic will also mean that governments can’t block such traffic without damaging their economies by risking blocking banking transactions.

As a former spy, he doesn’t think that spying is wrong. Precise, targeted spying makes sense in his view; its the bulk collection of data he sees as worrying and ineffective.

By the end of a fascinating, and often technical session, what everyone wanted to know was: would he do it again and when is he going home? Yes, was the answer to the first. I don’t know the answer to the second: it’s a political not a legal issue.

As for Enda Kenny and Hulk Hogan, well they were both on the same plane as me: the Hulk in business class and the Taoiseach in economy. We didn’t dine together; we didn’t drink together, but I was closer to them than to Snowden.

Related Articles

Senate Judiciary Advances Measure To Give Government Greater Control Over Online Content, Opens Risks For Online Security Through Patchwork Of State Laws

Jul 2, 2020

Washington — The Senate Judiciary Committee took a step toward approving legislation, S. 3398, the “Eliminating Abusive and Rampant Neglect of Interactive Technologies” (EARNIT) Act, which would weaken the law companies rely upon to address objectionable activity online, commonly referred to as Section 230. In March, when the bill was introduced, the Computer & Communications…

CCIA Expresses Concern Over New Senate Bill To Weaken Encryption

Jun 24, 2020

Washington — A bill to give law enforcement more access to personal data with fewer legal protections for citizens has been introduced in the Senate Tuesday. Senators Lindsey Graham, R-SC, and Tom Cotton, R-Ark., and Marsha Blackburn, R-Tenn., have announced the  “Lawful Access to Encrypted Data Act.” The bill would compel device manufacturers and providers…

CCIA Signs Joint OTI Letter Supporting Encryption

Dec 10, 2019

Washington — A day before a Senate Judiciary hearing on encryption, the Computer & Communications Industry Association joined 100 other organizations from around the world in a New America Open Technologies Institute letter  to officials in Australia, the U.S. and U.K expressing concern about their misconceptions about encryption.  CCIA, which represents device makers, internet services…