Scrapped Indian internet law is big win for freedom of speech online

BY Christian Borggreen
March 24, 2015

India’s Supreme Court today, March 24, vetoed a controversial 2009 amendment to India’s Information Technology Act.  The court found it unconstitutional as a restriction on freedom of speech online.

The amendment made posting information on social media of “grossly offensive or menacing character” punishable by up to three years in jail.

The law was challenged by a law student, Shreya Singhal, shortly after the arrest of two girls in Mumbai for a Facebook post criticising the shutdown of the city after a political leader’s death.  One of the two girls had merely “liked” the post according to the BBC.

While the court struck down the controversial amendment, it upheld another amendment which allows the government to block online content that “threatens the security of the state.”  Clearly, rights campaigners in India still have their work cut out for them.

The Court ruling in India does however mark some rare positive news for online rights in the region.  India was deemed “partly free” in terms of online expression in NGO Freedom House’ 2014 report.  The same report characterised its neighbours: China, Thailand, Vietnam, and Pakistan as “not free.”

The Court’s decision is a win for Internet users.  It may also strengthen the India’s democracy — the largest in the world with 1,267 million inhabitants.

Further protections for Internet intermediaries would give legal certainty for India’s booming tech sector.  It would help spur foreign investment, innovation, and job creation in the country, which may outpace China as the world’s fastest growing economy already this year, according to IMF Chief, Christine Lagarde.

Related Articles

White House Expected To Issue Executive Order Targeting Online Speech

May 28, 2020

Washington – According to various news reports, President Trump is expected to issue an executive order seeking to roll back the liability protections that have allowed users to post content online.  Reports of an executive order come days after Twitter applied a fact-check notice adjacent to accusations from President Trump via Twitter about alleged voter…

Tech Industry Raises Concerns with India’s Proposed Data Protection Bill

Mar 6, 2020

Washington — A group of 15 trade associations sent a letter to India policymakers this week expressing concerns with the proposed Personal Data Protection Bill.  In comments to the Parliamentary Committee last week, the Computer & Communications Industry outlined its specific concerns with the Bill and ways it departs from ongoing global discussion on data…

CCIA Asks Senate Judiciary To Extend And Strengthen USA FREEDOM Act Protections

Nov 5, 2019

Washington — The Senate Judiciary Committee holds its first hearing Wednesday on reauthorizing the USA FREEDOM Act of 2015. The Computer & Communications Industry Association is calling on senators to maintain due process and civil liberties protections for US citizens under current surveillance authority and to use this periodic reauthorization to re-evaluate whether the law…