Computer & Communication Industry Association
PublishedApril 8, 2016

Draft Feinstein-Burr Anti-Encryption Bill Would Seriously Harm Security, Speech, and Innovation Online

Washington — A discussion draft of Senators Feinstein and Burr’s long-awaited encryption access bill was released late Thursday night. The “Compliance with Court Orders Act of 2016” purports to require that digital service providers produce “intelligible data” in response to government demands pursuant to a court order, or provide “technical assistance” to achieve that end.

This bill would threaten the Internet’s viability as a platform for expression and commerce. Its most basic requirements are anathema to ensuring continued security and privacy online, and would do little to aid law enforcement efforts.

Encryption undergirds almost all financial transactions and communications on the Internet and connected devices. Requiring that companies either: 1) only employ encryption with keys they hold in escrow in anticipation of a government request, or 2) otherwise develop tools to undermine existing security measures would be a grave risk to the safety of users of digital devices and services. Both those keys and designed vulnerabilities would be prized targets for any bad actors seeking to have easy access to the communications, personal data, or financial information of any people or entities relying on readily available encryption. Of course, given the bill’s limited domestic jurisdiction, bad actors would themselves have easy access to secure products without imposed vulnerabilities from competitors abroad.

Worse still, the draft legislation goes far beyond even those untenable and unproductive requirements. The unprecedented breadth of the bill’s definitions of, among other things, “covered entities” and “intelligible” data, would extend to any person or company that develops a product or app that might encrypt or even delete data. It would further impress those companies or individuals who license software or operate third party app or software stores into policing the software and services they make available to ensure that they are compliant with the aforementioned broad “intelligible data” and “technical assistance” requirements in the bill. This content policing imposition runs counter to longstanding intermediary protections for providers of digital services.

The draft “Compliance with Court Orders Act” is a misguided attempt at addressing the suspect claim that encrypted devices and services hinder the work of law enforcement. Encryption is fundamental to almost all expressive and productive activity on the the Internet—Congress should strive to promote its availability and use, rather than undermine it.

News

CCIA Statement on One-Year Anniversary of U.S.-Korea Joint Fact Sheet on U.S.-Korean Economic Relations

The following statement may be attributable to CCIA VP Jonathan McHale on the occasion of the one-year anniversary of the understanding reached between the United States and South Korea on bilateral t...
reading-tablet
  • Statements
  • Trade
News

Estudo conclui que a Lei dos Mercados Digitais da UE não entregou os benefícios prometidos, enquanto outros países repensam regras semelhantes

Washington - Um novo estudo financiado pela Computer & Communications Industry Association (CCIA) conclui que a Lei dos Mercados Digitais (DMA, na sigla em inglês) da União Europeia impôs custo...
reading-tablet
  • Press Releases
  • Competition
News

Study Finds EU Digital Markets Act Has Failed to Deliver Promised Benefits, While Other Countries Rethink Similar Rules

Washington - A new study funded by the Computer & Communications Industry Association finds that the European Union’s Digital Markets Act (DMA) has imposed significant compliance costs while del...
reading-tablet
  • Press Releases
  • Competition
News

CCIA Raises Constitutional and Privacy Concerns with Kansas App Store Age Verification Proposals

Washington – The Computer & Communications Industry Association will testify today before the Kansas Legislature’s Special Committee on Protecting Children from Online Harm. CCIA will express ...
reading-tablet
  • Press Releases
  • Online Safety