Supreme Court Clears Up Design Patent Case

BY Heather Greenfield
December 6, 2016

Washington — The Supreme Court ruled unanimously Tuesday that a lower court made a mistake when it awarded all Samsung’s profits on several smartphone models to Apple based on design patent infringement. The Justices said design patent infringement can impact just a component of a product, not necessarily the entire product. The decision is likely to mean the lower court will modify its original award of nearly $400 million to Apple.

The Computer & Communications Industry Association filed an amicus brief arguing for the interpretation eventually adopted by the Court.

The following can be attributed to CCIA President & CEO Ed Black:

“This was a pivotal court case for the technology industry and it is encouraging to see the law interpreted and applied in a way that makes sense in a modern era and protects both inventors and innovation. The lower court’s interpretation of design patents, which allowed someone to sue based on an ornamental feature and reap the entire profits of someone else’s product, would have had a chilling effect on investment and the development of products – especially in the tech sector.”

The following can be attributed to CCIA patent counsel Matt Levy:

“Over the last decade, the Supreme Court has reversed the Federal Circuit about 80% of the time. Based on the questions asked during oral arguments in October, it looked likely the Justices would again modify a Federal Circuit decision, this time on design patents. The Court was asked to decide the scope of the so-called article of manufacture; it held that the Federal Circuit was wrong to say the article must always mean the entire end product sold to consumers. We are pleased to see that the Court correctly interpreted the law and did so unanimously. The outcome is one that will help bring the design patent statute into the modern electronic age. This ruling now means the Federal Circuit will have to fashion a test to determine the correct article of manufacture.”

Related Articles

CCIA Welcomes Nominees To Fill Out FCC, NTIA and PTO

Oct 26, 2021

Washington — President Biden has nominated people to key positions to oversee the U.S. tech industry today including at the US Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO), National Telecommunications and Information Administration (NTIA) and Federal Communications Commission (FCC).   The White House has nominated Acting Chairwoman Jessica Rosenworcel as the Commission’s permanent Chair, and Gigi Sohn, a…

CCIA Applauds Introduction of Bi-Partisan Bills To Increase Diversity And Transparency In The Patent System

Sep 22, 2021

Washington – U.S. Senators Patrick Leahy (D-VT), the Ranking Member and Chair of the Senate Intellectual Property Subcommittee, and Thom Tillis (R-NC) have introduced two bipartisan bills that promote transparency and diversity in the U.S. patent system.  One bill would require recording at the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office who owns a patent within 90…

The AIA At Ten: The Positive Impact of Inter Partes Review

Jul 12, 2021

The America Invents Act celebrates its tenth anniversary this year. This panel will examine perspectives from a variety of industries, ranging from life sciences to startups, on how the inter partes review process created in the AIA has improved patent quality, reduced patent litigation, and promoted progress in the innovation ecosystem.   The AIA At…