EU top court to decide if France’s “right to be forgotten” approach should apply globally

BY Christian Borggreen
July 19, 2017

Today a French court deferred to the EU’s highest court the question of whether a French “right to be forgotten” ruling should apply to online search results globally.

Essentially the EU’s top court will now have to decide if the balance between the right to free expression and the right to privacy should be struck by each country or if one (French) approach should apply for all globally.

Many organisations had expressed concerns with the French approach and its impact on freedom of speech, press freedom and the right to access information on the Internet.  A coalition of 29 media organisations commented “that French authorities had no right to force their interests on Internet users in other countries.”  Wikimedia had argued that “No single nation should attempt to control what information the entire world may access. This case would fundamentally undermine the Wikimedia vision of a world where every single human being can freely share in the sum of all knowledge.”

Given its global implications, including the potential for new conflicts of national laws, this new EU court proceeding will be one to watch…

Related Articles

CCIA Statement on Declaration on the Future of the Internet

Apr 28, 2022

Washington — The United States joined partners including the European Commission, Japan, Canada, Australia, and the United Kingdom today in the release of a “Declaration on the Future of the Internet”. The Declaration outlines aspirational standards for governments regarding digital governance and promotion of human rights online, and reinforces the importance of a multistakeholder approach…

EU Court Opinion Sets Limits to Use of Upload Filters in New EU Copyright Rules

Jul 15, 2021

Brussels, BELGIUM  — The EU top court’s Advocate General, Henrik Saugmandsgaard Øe, today provided his opinion on the Polish government’s request to annul the controversial Article 17 in the new EU Copyright rules. Poland requested that the Court of Justice of the EU (CJEU) annul Article 17 due to infringement of the right to freedom…