Court of Justice of the EU Delivers Judgment In Coty Germany Case on Online Marketplace Bans

BY Heather Greenfield
December 6, 2017

Brussels, BELGIUM —  The Court of Justice of the EU (CJEU) delivered its judgment in the Coty Germany case (Case C-230/16). The case deals with contractual provisions a producer of luxury cosmetics imposed on his authorized retailer, prohibiting the latter the sale of products on open online marketplaces. The key question in this case is whether these distribution restrictions are compatible with EU competition law or not.

In today’s judgment, the CJEU states that a producer of luxury goods may, under certain conditions, prohibit his authorized retailers from selling his products on third-party online marketplaces. According to the Court, this prohibition cannot as such be considered illegal under competition rules because it aims to preserve the luxury image of products if it fulfills certain conditions, such as being proportionate to the objective pursued.

The Computer & Communications Industry Association has advocated for open and competitive markets since 1972. Online marketplace bans have long been a concern because they deprive European sellers of more opportunities and consumers of more choice and price competition. The following can be attributed to Jakob Kucharczyk, Vice-President for Competition and EU Regulatory Policy:

“This judgement is bad news for consumers who will face fewer choices and also less competition when they want to shop online. It’s also a major setback for small firms across Europe that are trying to develop their online business while protecting major mass market brands. Today’s verdict does nothing to help foster the digital single market and to help innovative small firms to create jobs, grow online and reach out across European borders. Online marketplaces make the digital single market a reality today by enabling sellers to reach consumers across the EU.”

“At the same time, the need to preserve a luxury image of products stood very much at the centre of this case. The majority of marketplace bans do not concern luxury products, but mass market products that can be found in just about any physical store. The judgment is definitely not a carte blanche for manufacturers to impose absolute marketplace bans for all goods. In fact, the Court explicitly states that marketplace bans are only legal if they aim to preserve luxury image in a proportionate way. That would not be the case for the majority of today’s marketplace bans.”

Related Articles

New EU Distribution Rules Allow Discrimination Against Online Commerce

Jul 9, 2021

Brussels, BELGIUM — The European Commission has published its draft revisions to distribution rules known as the Vertical Block Exemption Regulation and the Vertical Guidelines (“VBER”). The VBER covers so-called vertical agreements between suppliers and their retailers or distributors. The updated rules replace the current rules on June 1, 2022. Digital distribution models have been…

CCIA Welcomes Review of EU Product Safety Rules

Jun 30, 2021

Brussels, BELGIUM — The European Commission today published its General Product Safety Regulation proposal. This long-awaited initiative will update the existing Directive to respond to new challenges related to digital technologies and online sales, while ensuring coherence with other Commission initiatives, in particular with the proposal for a Digital Services Act and the newly proposed…

CCIA Tech Industry Delegation Meets Incoming German EU Presidency, Shares Recommendations

Mar 9, 2020

Berlin, Germany — The Computer & Communications Industry Association is leading a delegation of tech companies to meet with German politicians and senior officials ahead of Germany taking over the Presidency of the Council of the EU on July 1. CCIA Europe will also present its EU tech policy recommendations published today.   Germany takes…