CCIA Asks PTO To Preserve Ability To Challenge Weak, Overly Broad Patents

BY Heather Greenfield
April 29, 2019

Washington — The Computer & Communications Industry Association has sent a letter to Patent and Trademark Office Director Iancu asking him not to implement new rules that would prevent challenges to weak or overly broad patents.

Senators Coons and Tillis sent a letter to PTO Director Iancu expressing concern over so-called “serial” IPR petitions.  The senators asked the PTO to deny inter partes review (IPR) petitions if another petition has already been filed, even if the first petitioner is a totally different party than the later petitioner.  This would have severe negative impacts on the IPR and patent system.

In the letter, CCIA patent counsel Josh Landau provided evidence that “serial” IPR petitions are extremely uncommon and cautioned that the requested changes to the rules would make it easier to game the patent system, preserving invalid patents from challenge. He offered an example that “a petition made based on weak prior art against a single minor claim could be used to deny any further petitions by any petitioner. Such a presumption would encourage gamesmanship by patent owners, triggering a weak challenge in order to bar future defendants from use of the inter partes procedure.”

Related Articles

The AIA At Ten: The Positive Impact of Inter Partes Review

Jul 12, 2021

The America Invents Act celebrates its tenth anniversary this year. This panel will examine perspectives from a variety of industries, ranging from life sciences to startups, on how the inter partes review process created in the AIA has improved patent quality, reduced patent litigation, and promoted progress in the innovation ecosystem.   The AIA At…

PTO Requests Comments On Changes To Make It Difficult To Challenge Weak Patents

Oct 19, 2020

Washington – The U.S. Patent and Trademark Office has requested comments on making permanent changes to the system currently used to challenge weak or overly broad patents known as inter partes review.  The Computer & Communications Industry Association sent a letter to Patent and Trademark Office Director Iancu last year warning him that making it…