Judge Grants Preliminary Injunction Blocking Unconstitutional Florida Law

BY Heather Greenfield
June 30, 2021

Washington — A Florida judge has ruled the state’s new law regulating internet speech violates the First Amendment and federal law and should not take effect tomorrow. U.S. District Judge Robert Hinkle said in a ruling issued Wednesday evening that the Florida law does not survive strict scrutiny and parts also are expressly preempted by federal law, and granted a preliminary injunction blocking the law.

The Computer & Communications Industry Association co-filed its lawsuit, motion for a preliminary injunction, and reply brief with NetChoice. The associations’ lawyers made their case Monday before the Tallahassee federal district court to stop the law from taking effect on July 1, in order to maintain the status quo while the parties litigate the broader legal issues.

By empowering bad actors to bring abusive lawsuits against digital services trying to protect users, the Florida statute would have paralyzed digital services’ trust & safety operations. This would have put American Internet users at greater risk to foreign disinformation and propaganda and extremism, predators and fraudsters, and viruses and malware, among other threats. It was slated to take effect July 1.  

The Computer & Communications Industry Association supports free speech online, which includes the right for private businesses to meet their users’ expectations about what type of material is appropriate for their community.

The following can be attributed to CCIA President Matt Schruers:

“This decision upholding the Constitution and federal law is encouraging, and reaffirms what we have been saying: Florida’s statute is an extraordinary overreach, designed to penalize private businesses for their perceived lack of deference to the Government’s political ideology.  The court’s ruling is a win for internet users and the First Amendment.”

 

 

Related Articles

CCIA, NetChoice Request Preliminary Injunction Against Unconstitutional Texas Social Media Law

Sep 30, 2021

Washington — The Computer & Communications Industry Association and NetChoice have co-filed a motion for a preliminary injunction against Texas’s new law allowing people to sue social media companies for performing content moderation on anything from anti-American propaganda to fraud on their sites. The injunction is expected to keep the law from taking effect December 2nd while…

Texas Governor Signs Unconstitutional Social Media Law Making It Easier To Sue Companies For Protecting Users Online

Sep 9, 2021

Washington — Texas Gov. Greg Abbott has signed an unconstitutional bill that seeks to punish social media companies for following policies that protect internet users from dangerous content online. The legislation, which undermines First Amendment rights, would encourage lawsuits when content from anyone from those engaged in online scams to nefarious foreign actors is removed.…

Texas Legislators Approve Bill Making It Easier To Sue Companies For Policies Protecting Users Online

Aug 30, 2021

Washington — In a special session today, the Texas House passed a bill that would require companies to follow new guidance for enforcing content moderation policies.  Passage of the law comes after a federal judge ruled in favor of CCIA’s challenge to a similar Florida law, blocking it temporarily and noting the Florida law likely…