Governor DeSantis Calls Special Session To Retract Disney Carveout In Unconstitutional Florida Social Media Law

BY Heather Greenfield
April 19, 2022

Washington – Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis has called a special legislative session to ask lawmakers to amend a “social media censorship” law that a Florida judge ruled unconstitutional. The ruling came last year and the case is now on appeal at the Eleventh Circuit, which will hear oral argument next week.

The law would force companies to carry content from all users online including those engaged in fraud or foreign adversaries promoting propaganda, but gave a unique “theme park” carveout for Disney, which Gov. DeSantis now wants to revoke.

Florida lawmakers were warned when they passed the bill that it violated the First Amendment as that protects both the right of individuals and companies to speak or not to be compelled to speak. Defending the law against constitutional challenges has cost Florida taxpayers an estimated $700,000 so far according to documents obtained by the Computer & Communications Industry Association, which successfully challenged the law in court alongside NetChoice. However, the plans to amend the bill would not fix the underlying constitutional problems.

CCIA supports free speech online, which includes the right for private businesses to meet their users’ expectations about what type of material is appropriate for their community.

The following can be attributed to CCIA President Matt Schruers:

“If Governor DeSantis had realized sooner that the Internet regulations his own office lobbied for were wrong, he might have saved Floridians hundreds of thousands of dollars in legal expenses.  But this law is wrong not because the legislature carved out a once-favored Florida company, but because the Government has no business dictating what speech private businesses must host.”

 

Related Articles

Supreme Court Agrees To Hear Two Cases Involving Online Content

Oct 3, 2022

Washington – The Supreme Court announced it would hear two cases this term involving content online, Gonzalez v. Google and Twitter v. Taamneh. The cases challenge companies for allegedly not doing enough to address dangerous content on their sites at a time when several state legislatures are seeking to tie companies’ hands, arguing they are…

Senate Judiciary Committee Approves JCPA

Sep 22, 2022

Washington – The Senate Judiciary Committee has approved S. 673, the Journalism Competition and Preservation Act, after a new amendment was adopted during the markup Thursday. This follows partisan disagreement over the controversial legislation, which proposes to exempt some news media outlets from antitrust laws and encourages the formation of a news cartel. Unfortunately the…

CCIA Statement on Florida’s Petition To U.S. Supreme Court In Social Media Law Case

Sep 21, 2022

Washington – Florida has filed a legal brief asking the Supreme Court to hear the case challenging its social media law, which an appeals court struck down in May as unconstitutional. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit ruled unanimously in a 3-0 decision that Florida’s social media censorship law violated the First…