New Economic Impact Analysis Reveals Cost of Proposed Tech Regulations Would Total up to $109 Billion for Public Sector Workers; $1.02 Trillion for U.S. Investors

May 20, 2022

Washington – A new economic impact analysis by the Computer & Communications Industry Association reveals that proposed regulations in antitrust bills like S. 2992 and H.R. 3816 would come at a major cost for U.S. investors and pension plan members such as teachers, firefighters, and nurses. Troubling findings show that by the late 2030s, increased operating costs for companies regulated by the proposed legislation would reduce their market value significantly, causing up to $109 billion in losses to public sector pension plans and $1.02 trillion to investors in S&P 500 index funds and large cap firms.

The analysis extends a methodology used in a recent National Economic Research Associates (NERA) study that found that the bills would regulate five U.S. companies upon enactment, increasing their operating costs by $319 billion and reducing firm market value accordingly. In the near term, 13 additional U.S. companies would be regulated and incur losses. By the late 2030s, over 100 U.S. companies would be regulated at a cost of up to $1.02 Trillion for U.S. investors.

The analysis reveals the particularly concerning impact the proposed regulations would have on public sector workers’ pension plans. On average, 86% of public sector pension plans count 5 companies that would be immediately regulated by the bills among their top 10 holdings. Virtually all of their top 10 holdings would be impacted by the 2030s, suffering up to $109 billion in losses, or up to $3,928 per pension plan member. CCIA has created an interactive map that displays the expected aggregate and individual losses for public sector workers on a state-by-state basis. 

The Computer & Communications Industry Association has advocated for tech policy that advances competition and innovation for 50 years. The following can be attributed to CCIA Director of Research and Economics Trevor Wagener:

“Tech regulatory bills like S. 2992 and H.R. 3816 would cost U.S. investors up to a trillion dollars from increased operating costs and reduced market value. Public sector worker pension plans are leading shareholders of companies that would be regulated under the bills and face losses up to $109 billion. As a result, for tens of millions of Americans who are members of such pension plans, the average expected harm is up to nearly $4,000 per person. Supporters of the bills have offered no quantitative economic analysis of the costs and benefits of the bills that show any quantifiable benefits for those Americans in return.”

Related Articles

Problems With JCPA Focus Of CCIA Ad Campaign

Washington – The Computer & Communications Industry Association launched an ad campaign opposing legislation being considered by Congress that would compel some digital services to host dangerous content that violates their terms of service on misinformation. CCIA also objects to the JCPA being attached to must-pass legislation like the National Defense Authorization Act.  Along with…

CCIA Offers Comments On Saudi Arabia’s Draft Regulations For Digital Platforms

Washington – The Computer & Communications Industry Association submitted comments to Saudi Arabia’s Communications & Information Technology Commission on its proposed Draft Competition Regulations for Digital Content Platforms. CCIA recommended gathering more information including from various stakeholders to fully understand market dynamics and cautioned that overly burdensome regulations aimed to carve out particular market players…

CCIA Submits Comments To Turkish Competition Authority

Washington – The Turkish Competition Authority is working on an amendment to the country’s “Protection of Competition Law” in an attempt to address potential competition and regulatory issues in digital markets. The Computer & Communications Industry Association (CCIA) filed comments  recommending more research into whether there are market distortions that need to be addressed by…